Let the Sky Fall by Shannon Messenger
Book One of the Sky Fall series
Publisher: Simon Pulse
Publication Date: March 5, 2013
Rating: 4 stars
Source: ARC won from a giveaway
Summary (from Goodreads):
Vane Weston should have died in the category-five tornado that killed his parents. Instead, he woke up in a pile of rubble with no memories of his past - except one: a beautiful, dark-haired girl standing in the winds. She swept through his dreams ever since, and he clings to the hope that she's real.
Audra is real, but she isn't human. She's a sylph, an air elemental who can walk on the wind, translate its alluring songs, even twist it into a weapon. She's also a guardian - Vane's guardian - and has sworn an oath to protect him at all costs.
When a hasty mistake reveals their location to the enemy who murdered both their families, Audra has just days to help Vane unlock his memories. And as the storm winds gather, Audra and Vane start to realize that the greatest danger might not be the warriors coming to destroy them, but the forbidden romance growing between them.
What I Liked:
I was actually really surprised by how much I enjoyed this book! I'm pleased that I enjoyed it as much as I did, but I'm surprised. I'd read a fair amount of positive reviews for this book, when it initially came out last year, but then I read a few reviews that pretty much picked this book apart. Those few negative reviews from bloggers I actively followed were enough for me to put off reading this book for about a year.
But then I had to go and request this book from Edelweiss, and of course I was approved, so I had to be sure to read the first book (this one) before reading the sequel. Good time to binge-read, right? If only I had the third book, too. Then I could read the entire series and be happy.
Vane survived a category-five tornado, and he remembers one thing: Audra. For years, he sees Audra in his dreams, the one thing from the fatal storm that seems to be consistent in his non-memories. But the Audra comes back. And she reveals everything to him - including the key facts that he is a Westerly, a future king of the Windwalkers, and the future of the Windwalkers.
This book is split into Audra and Vane's perspective. We get Vane's perspective first, so I immediately bonded with him first. Usually, the first character introduced is the one I like more. I wasn't always a fan of Audra (especially with what she did - she seemed to be the reason for all of the "bad"), but I didn't mind Audra.
In Audra's mind, Vane seems to be a bit obnoxious and cocky and irritating. In Vane's mind, Audra is perfect and broken. In MY opinion, Vane is a bit cocky and sometimes obnoxious, but I think he is also scared yet determined. He is confident, but he also recognizes the fact that he has no idea what he is doing. Audra is NOT perfect. She is definitely broken up over what happened years ago, and she shoulders the blame, the burden, and the responsibility of basically EVERYTHING.
All of that said, I definitely preferred Vane's perspective to Audra's perspective. I found Vane more interesting than Audra, and more authentic. Not that Audra wasn't authentic, but I didn't like her voice as much as I liked Vane's. But I DID like the dual-perspective dynamic - Messenger definitely did a great job in making the voices unique and interesting, and it worked in this book.
The romance was pretty sweet, nice even. I thought it was a bit insta-lovey, but I liked seeing Vane and Audra together. The whole book seemed like torture for the two of them, but the end of this book proved to be pretty great for the two of them. We'll see though, as the series goes on. There will be some serious consequences for the two of them.
The majority of this novel is focused on Vane and Audra training and preparing for the Stormers (I think they are called Stormers?) and Raiden to come. This didn't bother me too much, but it was a little bit slow. A lot of discoveries and plot twists happened during this time, but actually events, meh.
Otherwise, the plot of this book was pretty good - straightforward, with several plot twisters (hehe, wind pun!). I enjoyed the book from start to finish, and wanted to keep reading. I read this book from cover to cover in one sitting, which was nice. I can't wait to read the second book! Which is hilarious, because I'm reading it tomorrow.
What I Did Not Like:
As I said before, I think the romance was a bit insta-lovey. Like, immediately upon seeing Audra, Vane sees to become obsessed with her. I know he's been seeing her in his dreams for years and all, but he just becomes ENAMORED. Audra falls in love more gradually, which was nice (and interesting) to see.
I'm also kind of mad at Audra, for basically causing everything (she didn't REALLY, but that's how it seems). Like, a bird is not that important. But then I'm also mad at another people, like Audra's mother, for being a jerk, and Raiden, for being power hungry in general. I guess I don't like these events and characters, but I see their purpose. Sort of.
And I mentioned that the plot was a bit simplistic - meaning, the majority of the book was spent following Vane's training with Audra. Cool, but at the same time, can other things happen? Also, I'm a bit confused about how everything went down in the end, but I'm just going to roll with it and read the second book. Sounds like a plan, right? Right.
Also, I think the majority of the Windwalkers are full of BS. They want to pin the future of their race on one boy, on one person. They have all these rules and terms and conditions laid out for him, his entire life planned for him. It's like he's going to magically adjust to being a Windwalker (after seventeen years of NOT using his wind-related abilities), and he's definitely going to leave his old life behind and agree to everything they want to do (including that bit with Solana... um, NO). Full of BS, I say.
Would I Recommend It:
I would definitely recommend this book to fans of a good forbidden romance! And the paranormal aspect is pretty cool. And Messenger does a really great job of creating a contemporary world with a paranormal aspect (or a paranormal world with a contemporary feel? Whatever).
3.5 stars -> rounded up to 4 stars. This book was pretty great! I can't wait to read the sequel. Check out my review, coming tomorrow (February 17th) on my blog!
Was this review helpful? Please let me know in the comments section!
Great review sweetie :D I really enjoyed this book as well. <3 I'm glad you didn't hate it, hih :D Can't wait to read your review for book two; which I enjoyed as well ;p Thank you for sharing. <3ReplyDelete
Thank you! I didn't hate it, which is always a nice feeling. I'm glad you enjoyed book two! You're very welcome, Carina.Delete
I've been meaning to read Let the Sky Fall for a while now, it's just been staring at me and taunting me for not reading it :oReplyDelete
It's interesting that you enjoyed Vane's perspective over Audra's. I'm definitely excited to meet Vane now :D Sometimes dual perspective books don't work for me, but I'm happy that this one seemed to work for you! x)
How could I ever resist my forbidden romances? :3 Let the Sky Fall definitely moved up higher on my reading list, especially because the sequel comes out next month. Thanks for wonderful review! :D
Kaede @ Wake Up at Seven
I hope you read this book! And discover the awesomeness that is Vane! I like dual POVs - for the most part. I'm not a *huge* fan of the forbidden romance, but every so often, I permit myself to read a book or series involving one.Delete
You're welcome - and thank YOU!
I've had this one on the wish list. Glad its a good one even with those reservations. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.ReplyDelete
It's pretty good! Thank YOU, Sophia.Delete
Darn you, insta-love! How many more must you claim for the Dark Side? Still, it may be worth a go since it has wind magic. ;)ReplyDelete
Ha! It's not *too* bad in this book, but I think it's there. And I agree with you - the concept is unique and interesting, so that's that!Delete
I enjoyed this one too. I'll be reading the sequel this month--hoping the love it built up a bit more because like you I felt it was a bit insta love. So glad you enjoyed this!ReplyDelete
I'm glad to hear that, Kristen! I hope you enjoy the sequel as well. Thank you!Delete
Aww insta-love is definitely an instant turn-off, but it sounds like the rest of the book was good. I usually like the first perspective of a book better, mainly because they're usually the main character of the story, but I can see how Vane would be the more attractive point of view. Glad you liked this book, Alyssa!ReplyDelete
I think the rest of the book was pretty good! And yes, we are alike in that way, Eileen. Vane is definitely my favorite. Thank you!Delete
Awesome reviews Alyssa I'm glad and happy you enjoyed this book so much I heard mix reviews about this one and I didn't now if I should try to read it or not but after reading your review I am going to give it a try! thanks for sharing Alyssa!ReplyDelete
You're right, this book has received mixed reviews. If you get a chance, give it a go!Delete
I have wanted to read this for a long time. This is one of the few books (more, recently) that I haven't read reviews for. Well, now I have. So my expectations have been none. It makes me happy to know that, while definitely not perfect, it really is a good story. I am looking forward to reading your review of the second book and seeing if the goodness continues!ReplyDelete
That's good to hear! And now I suppose you have some expectations? I love the uniqueness of the story. Hopefully, my review of book two isn't too disappointing!Delete
I really enjoyed this one! I was actually surprised of how much I liked it and how unique the story was!ReplyDelete
Great review, Alyssa!
That's good! I think the idea was pretty unique. I was also kind of surprised that I enjoyed it! Hope you love book two.Delete
If you like Shannon Messenger, than you should read Keeper of the Lost Cities! It is her other series. It is way different than Let the Sky Fall, but anyone who likes Shannon Messenger should definitely check it out!ReplyDelete
I'm not really into Middle Grade, but I do have a few of the books in case I change my mind. =)Delete