Monday, September 9, 2013

Review: Thornhill by Kathleen Peacock

Thornhill by Kathleen Peacock
Book Two of the Hemlock series
Publisher: Katherine Tegen Books
Publication Date: September 10, 2013
Rating: 4 stars
Source: ARC sent by the author

Summary (from Goodreads):

Mac can’t lose another friend. Even if he doesn't want to be found.

The ripple effect caused by Mac’s best friend Amy’s murder has driven Mac’s new love, Kyle, to leave Hemlock and disappear from her life forever. But Mac knows that Kyle plans to enroll in a rehabilitation camp, where he can live with other werewolves. She refuses to accept his decision, especially since the camps are rumored to be tortuous. So she sets out in search of Kyle with a barely sober Jason—and Amy’s all-seeing ghost—in tow.

Clues lead Mac to find Kyle in a werewolf den in Colorado—but their reunion is cut short by a Tracker raid. Now Mac and Kyle are trapped inside the electric fences of Thornhill, a camp for young werewolves. As she devises an escape plan, Mac uncovers dangerous secrets buried within the walls of Thornhill—and realizes that the risk to the people she loves is greater than ever before.

What I Liked:

Confession time: I've had an ARC of this book since April. And I just decided to crack it open in July. Sequels are weird creations. If it's the second book of a series - particularly a trilogy - then I automatically will be afraid to read the sequel. Because often in YA, with trilogies, authors like to kill someone or take someone way or separate the protagonists, at the end of the sequel. For example: The Crown of Embers by Rae Carson, Fractured by Sarah Fine, Prodigy by Marie Lu (didn't read that one actually, but I've heard some things).  

Sequels are scary! In sequels, the protagonist is tested. He/she must suffer for the decisions made in book one. Relationships are tested, and often in trilogy sequels, if a second love interest wasn't already introduced in book one, he/she is introduced in book two. OR, book two is focused more on the secondary love interest.

See why I am scared of sequels? Well, let me put your fears of THIS sequel to rest. This book does not end in one of the primary or secondary characters dying, or the protagonists being separated, or anything of which I was afraid. Huzzah! I can sleep at night!

Seriously though. This book was awesome. Mac leaves her home with Jason and Serena to find Kyle. All she does, all the decisions she makes, is for Kyle. When they finally meet (that's not a spoiler, you knew they would), things happen... and everyone - all the wolves and Mac included - are sent to Thornhill, a camp for werewolves.

The majority of the book is set in Thornhill. Mac and a werewolf Eve try and find a way to get themselves and Kyle and Serena out. Enter Jason, who wasn't captured and sent to Thornhill, because he was human. He comes to Thornhill as a counselor. The whole gang is in Thornhill, with seemingly no way out.

I loved that part of the book - how well Peacock wrote the camp. I was terrified of reading parts of the book that was in the camp, because it was scary! What if they got caught? What if Mac was found to be human, and just pretending to be a werewolf? What if one of them lost control, or got killed, or was taken to Willowgrove?

So many things could go wrong. And in the end, things did go wrong. And right. I can say that the ending is a good ending, a happy ending, despite everything that happened at Thornhill. This sequel did one thing that sequels should do - it took the series plot to a whole new level. Book one was about Amy's death... book two is about werewolf rights (sort of).

The romance is there, but it's not front and center. I love how Peacock makes sure readers remember that Mac and Kyle are our primary couple, and that they love each other. BUT, she also makes this book more about getting out of Thornhill than anything else. Saving each other is important... but so is getting out.

YAY for Thornhill! I really shouldn't have been so afraid of reading this book, because it's an excellent sequel - possibly one of the best sequels I've read.

What I Did Not Like:

The ending is a little... bittersweet. It ends well, but there is something specific about it that is sad. I don't know what Peacock has planned for the rest of the series, but I hope there is a happy ending overall! Like I said before, the ending is good... but it leaves you with a bittersweet taste in your mouth.

Or whatever that phrase is.

Would I Recommend It:

YES! Let's say you didn't like Hemlock: read Thornhill anyway. Liked/loved Hemlock? You're good to go! Didn't read Hemlock? Read it, and this one!


4 stars. This book did not fall victim to the sophomore/sequel slump!

Was this review helpful? Please let me know in the comments section!


  1. YAY! Glad you enjoyed it :D I'm dying to read it. <3 Loved book one. And omg, yes. Sequels are scary. Glad this one wasn't :D And ahh. Kyle and Mac. <3 LOVE them together. Awesome review. <3

    1. I hope you enjoy Thornhill! It comes out tomorrow! This sequel was simply DIVINE :D Thank you, Carina!

  2. I skimmed a bit over the review since I haven't read Hemlock myself (it's there, added in the TBR list, I'll get to it eventually!) but so glad that the second book doesn't have a middle book syndrome case!

    Thank you for a great review!

    1. Totally understandable! I do that too. It's always nice to here that a series that you WANT to read has a great first book and an awesome second book. Thank YOU, Pili!

  3. OMG! You had an ARC and didn't read it?! I read Hemlock as an ARC and was dying for this one since I read the last page! And alas, I didn't manage to get an ARC. Or early copy! Still waiting for my preorder to arrive! Scary thing is, I ordered it months and months ago and the email that was sent to me to confirm said order said that it would ship on September 28!! I am so very hoping that that was a computer glitch or something, because I think I will die a bit if I have to wait til October to read this one!!

    Rambling aside...I LOVED Hemlock so I cannot wait to read this one! Your review was amazing! I am ever more looking forward to this one!

    1. Ermmm... lol ;)

      I wouldn't worry! You'll definitely get your book before that. If you ordered via Amazon, you probably grouped your shipments into as few orders as possible, which delays shipping.

      I hope you love Thornhill as much as I did! Or more, I suppose. Thank you so much, Jessica!

  4. Oh Oh Oh I skip this review because I haven't read Thornhill yet but I know it is an awesome review yayyyy I am so happy you liked it I can't wait to read this one tomorrow I've been dying to read it since I finished reading Hemlock! which was an awesome book! thanks for sharing Alyssa!

    1. LOL good idea! I'm glad you enjoyed Hemlock! I see that you're binge-reading the series - smart choice! Thank you so much for the comment - and I love your enthusiasm! :D


I love comments! I will always try and reply to your comments, as well as leave some comment love on your blog! :)

Also, this an award and tag free blog. While I am flattered that you would think of me, I really do not have the time to follow up. Thank you!